Sesame 1st Birthday

Celebrate your child's first birthday with Elmo, Big Bird and the rest of the gang by hosting a Sesame Street themed birthday with our Sesame Street 1st birthday party supplies. Every little kid loves Sesame Street so you know they'll love this idea! To help you get started, we've put together all-in-one kits that include everything you will need in order to host a birthday that no one will forget. These feature balloon kits, decorations kits and tableware kits. These kits make decorating and hosting a birthday party extremely simple with little to no hassle.

Sesame 1st Birthday party supplies


Tableware Back To Top
Create your own themed party or add to your party
  • Sesame Street 1st Birthday Cake Plates (18-pack)

    Sesame Street 1st Birthday Cake Plates (18-pack)

    MSRP: $7.55 Our Price: $3.77
    In Stock
  • Sesame Street 1st Beverage Napkins (36-pack)

    Sesame Street 1st Beverage Napkins (36-pack)

    MSRP: $7.60 Our Price: $3.80
    In Stock
  • Sesame Street 1st Birthday Dinner Plates (18-pack)

    Sesame Street 1st Birthday Dinner Plates (18-pack)

    MSRP: $12.55 Our Price: $6.27
    In Stock
  • Sesame Street 1st Birthday Napkins (36-pack)

    Sesame Street 1st Birthday Napkins (36-pack)

    MSRP: $9.99 Our Price: $5.00
    In Stock
  • Sesame Street 1st Birthday Cups (18-pack)

    Sesame Street 1st Birthday Cups (18-pack)

    MSRP: $6.99 Our Price: $3.50
    In Stock
  • Sesame Street 1st Birthday Table Cover (each)

    Sesame Street 1st Birthday Table Cover (each)

    Our Price: $4.99
    In Stock
  • Elmo Beverage Napkins (16-pack)

    Elmo Beverage Napkins (16-pack)

    MSRP: $4.19 Our Price: $2.09
    In Stock
  • Elmo Cake Plates (8-pack)

    Elmo Cake Plates (8-pack)

    MSRP: $3.99 Our Price: $2.00
    In Stock
  • Elmo Napkins (16-pack)

    Elmo Napkins (16-pack)

    MSRP: $5.19 Our Price: $2.59
    In Stock
  • Elmo Dinner Plates (8-pack)

    Elmo Dinner Plates (8-pack)

    MSRP: $5.19 Our Price: $2.59
    In Stock
  • Yellow Tableware

    Yellow Tableware

    Our Price: $0.01
    Out of Stock
  • Red Tableware

    Red Tableware

    Our Price: $0.01
    Out of Stock
  • Lime Tableware

    Lime Tableware

    Our Price: $0.01
    Out of Stock
  • Orange Tableware

    Orange Tableware

    Our Price: $0.01
    Out of Stock
  • All-In-One Party Kits Back To Top
  • Sesame Street 1st Birthday Favor Kit (for 1 Guest)

    Sesame Street 1st Birthday Favor Kit (for 1 Guest)

    Our Price: $6.99
    In Stock
    CHOKING HAZARD--Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Sesame Street 1st Birthday Decoration Kit

    Sesame Street 1st Birthday Decoration Kit

    Our Price: $30.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame 1st Birthday Balloon Kit

    Sesame 1st Birthday Balloon Kit

    Our Price: $16.99
    In Stock
  • DIY Decorate a Mug and Crayons Kit (Each)

    DIY Decorate a Mug and Crayons Kit (Each)

    Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
  • Elmo Pull-String Pinata Kit

    Elmo Pull-String Pinata Kit

    Our Price: $37.99
    In Stock
  • Elmo Pull-String Pinata Kit

    Elmo Pull-String Pinata Kit

    Our Price: $29.99
    In Stock
  • Bath Time Ultimate Favor Kit (for 1 Guest)

    Bath Time Ultimate Favor Kit (for 1 Guest)

    Our Price: $7.39
    In Stock
    CHOKING HAZARD--Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Bath Time Favor Kit (for 1 Guest)

    Bath Time Favor Kit (for 1 Guest)

    Our Price: $6.99
    In Stock
    CHOKING HAZARD--Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Sesame Street 1St Birthday Decorating Kit (Each)

    Sesame Street 1St Birthday Decorating Kit (Each)

    Our Price: $9.99
    In Stock
  • 1st Birthday Favor Kit (for 1 Guest)

    1st Birthday Favor Kit (for 1 Guest)

    Our Price: $7.29
    In Stock
  • Sesame Street 1st Birthday Ultimate Tableware Kit Serves 16 Guests

    Sesame Street 1st Birthday Ultimate Tableware Kit Serves 16 Guests

    Our Price: $70.99
    In Stock
  • Party Favors & Candy Back To Top
  • Sesame Street 1st Birthday Favor Kit (for 1 Guest)

    Sesame Street 1st Birthday Favor Kit (for 1 Guest)

    Our Price: $6.99
    In Stock
    CHOKING HAZARD--Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Deluxe Sesame Street 1st Birthday Favor Kit (for 1 Guest)

    Deluxe Sesame Street 1st Birthday Favor Kit (for 1 Guest)

    Our Price: $9.99
    In Stock
    CHOKING HAZARD--Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • DIY Decorate a Mug and Crayons Kit (Each)

    DIY Decorate a Mug and Crayons Kit (Each)

    Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
  • Bath Time Ultimate Favor Kit (for 1 Guest)

    Bath Time Ultimate Favor Kit (for 1 Guest)

    Our Price: $7.39
    In Stock
    CHOKING HAZARD--Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Bath Time Favor Kit (for 1 Guest)

    Bath Time Favor Kit (for 1 Guest)

    Our Price: $6.99
    In Stock
    CHOKING HAZARD--Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • 1st Birthday Favor Kit (for 1 Guest)

    1st Birthday Favor Kit (for 1 Guest)

    Our Price: $7.29
    In Stock
  • First Birthday Deluxe Favor Kit

    First Birthday Deluxe Favor Kit

    Our Price: $6.99
    In Stock
  • Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Lollipops (pack of 12)

    Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Lollipops (pack of 12)

    Our Price: $13.99
    In Stock
  • Blue Candy

    Blue Candy

    Our Price: $0.01
    In Stock
  • Green Candy

    Green Candy

    Our Price: $0.01
    In Stock
  • Orange Candy

    Orange Candy

    Our Price: $0.01
    In Stock
  • Red Candy

    Red Candy

    Our Price: $0.01
    In Stock
  • Yellow Candy

    Yellow Candy

    Our Price: $0.01
    In Stock
  • Red Candy Buffet Decorating Kit (Each)

    Red Candy Buffet Decorating Kit (Each)

    Our Price: $64.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Street Coloring & Activity Book (Each)

    Sesame Street Coloring & Activity Book (Each)

    Our Price: $2.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Street Favor Container (Each)

    Sesame Street Favor Container (Each)

    Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Street 1st Birthday Loot Bags

    Sesame Street 1st Birthday Loot Bags

    Our Price: $2.99
    In Stock
  • Crayon Bubbles (each)

    Crayon Bubbles (each)

    Our Price: $0.79
    In Stock
    CHOKING HAZARD--Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Rainbow Scratch Art Boards Set (Each)

    Rainbow Scratch Art Boards Set (Each)

    Our Price: $1.49
    In Stock
  • Swirl Lollipop (12-pack)

    Swirl Lollipop (12-pack)

    Our Price: $6.99
    In Stock
  • Yellow Treat Favor Boxes (6 Pack)

    Yellow Treat Favor Boxes (6 Pack)

    Our Price: $2.49
    In Stock
  • Bathtub Boat (each)

    Bathtub Boat (each)

    Our Price: $3.00
    In Stock
  • Blue Treat Favor Boxes (6 Pack)

    Blue Treat Favor Boxes (6 Pack)

    Our Price: $2.49
    In Stock
  • One Straw (12-pack)

    One Straw (12-pack)

    Our Price: $5.99
    In Stock
  • Loom Rubber Bands (300 Pieces)

    Loom Rubber Bands (300 Pieces)

    MSRP: $2.49 Clearance Price: $0.75
    In Stock
  • Red Treat Favor Boxes (6 Pack)

    Red Treat Favor Boxes (6 Pack)

    Our Price: $2.49
    In Stock
  • Playtime Dough (Each - Assorted Colors)

    Playtime Dough (Each - Assorted Colors)

    Our Price: $0.89
    Out of Stock
    CHOKING HAZARD--Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Krazy Straw (12-pack)

    Krazy Straw (12-pack)

    MSRP: $6.99 Clearance Price: $4.99
    In Stock
  • Gift Box 10Oz. Sipper Cup W/ Krazy Straw (Each)

    Gift Box 10Oz. Sipper Cup W/ Krazy Straw (Each)

    Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
  • Glitter Balls (each)

    Glitter Balls (each)

    Our Price: $2.99
    In Stock
  • Tub Tints (each)

    Tub Tints (each)

    MSRP: $2.09 Our Price: $1.59
    In Stock
  • Mini Game Bubbles (each)

    Mini Game Bubbles (each)

    Our Price: $1.19
    In Stock
    CHOKING HAZARD--Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Handprint Kit (makes 1)

    Handprint Kit (makes 1)

    Our Price: $7.99
    In Stock
    CHOKING HAZARD--Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Solid Favor Tote (12 pack)

    Solid Favor Tote (12 pack)

    Our Price: $14.99
    Out of Stock
  • Giggle Rattle (each)

    Giggle Rattle (each)

    Our Price: $3.99
    In Stock
  • Elastic Bands Lolliband Favor (Each)

    Elastic Bands Lolliband Favor (Each)

    Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
  • Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Lip Balm (12 Pack)

    Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Lip Balm (12 Pack)

    Our Price: $9.99
    In Stock
  • Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Mini Stickers (Sheet of 20)

    Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Mini Stickers (Sheet of 20)

    Our Price: $2.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Friends Personalized Favor Mugs (Each)

    Sesame Friends Personalized Favor Mugs (Each)

    Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Friends Personalized Mini Stickers (Sheet of 20)

    Sesame Friends Personalized Mini Stickers (Sheet of 20)

    Our Price: $2.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Friends Personalized Bubbles (18 Pack)

    Sesame Friends Personalized Bubbles (18 Pack)

    Our Price: $9.99
    In Stock
  • Chubbie Vehicles (each)

    Chubbie Vehicles (each)

    Our Price: $1.99
    Out of Stock
  • Bucket And Shovel (each)

    Bucket And Shovel (each)

    Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
    CHOKING HAZARD--Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Balloons Back To Top
  • Sesame 1st Birthday Balloon Kit

    Sesame 1st Birthday Balloon Kit

    Our Price: $16.99
    In Stock
  • Elmo Airwalker Balloon (each)

    Elmo Airwalker Balloon (each)

    Our Price: $19.99
    In Stock
  • Cookie Monster Balloon (each)

    Cookie Monster Balloon (each)

    Our Price: $7.99
    In Stock
  • Elmo Balloon (each)

    Elmo Balloon (each)

    Our Price: $6.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Street 1st Birthday Balloon (each)

    Sesame Street 1st Birthday Balloon (each)

    Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Street 1st Birthday Mylar Balloon Bouquet (each)

    Sesame Street 1st Birthday Mylar Balloon Bouquet (each)

    Our Price: $9.99
    In Stock
  • Red Star Mylar Balloon (each)

    Red Star Mylar Balloon (each)

    Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
  • Royal Blue Star Balloon (each)

    Royal Blue Star Balloon (each)

    Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
  • Lime Star Mylar Balloon (each)

    Lime Star Mylar Balloon (each)

    Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
  • Orange Star Mylar Balloon (each)

    Orange Star Mylar Balloon (each)

    Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
  • Lavender Star Mylar Balloon (each)

    Lavender Star Mylar Balloon (each)

    Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
  • Solid Curling Ribbon (each)

    Solid Curling Ribbon (each)

    Our Price: $0.69
    In Stock
  • Solid Latex Balloons (10-pack)

    Solid Latex Balloons (10-pack)

    Our Price: $1.29
    In Stock
    CHOKING HAZARD--Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Balloon Drop Bag 80" (Each)

    Balloon Drop Bag 80" (Each)

    Our Price: $3.99
    In Stock
  • Balloon Stick-Ups

    Balloon Stick-Ups

    Our Price: $1.49
    In Stock
  • Latex 12" Dots Balloons (6 Pack)

    Latex 12" Dots Balloons (6 Pack)

    Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
  • 50ft Balloon Decorating Strip (Each)

    50ft Balloon Decorating Strip (Each)

    Our Price: $7.99
    In Stock
  • Mylar Number Balloons (each)

    Mylar Number Balloons (each)

    Our Price: $7.99
    In Stock
  • Sticky Tack Value Pack

    Sticky Tack Value Pack

    Our Price: $3.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Balloon Pump (each)

    Balloon Pump (each)

    Our Price: $4.99
    In Stock
  • 25ft Balloon Decorating Strip (Each)

    25ft Balloon Decorating Strip (Each)

    Our Price: $3.99
    In Stock
  • Ultra Hi-Float Balloon Treatment Kit 16oz (Each)

    Ultra Hi-Float Balloon Treatment Kit 16oz (Each)

    Our Price: $11.99
    In Stock
  • Premium Assorted Latex 36" Balloons (6 Pack)

    Premium Assorted Latex 36" Balloons (6 Pack)

    Our Price: $14.99
    In Stock
  • Disposable Helium Tank 14.9 Cubic Ft.

    Disposable Helium Tank 14.9 Cubic Ft.

    Our Price: $59.99
    In Stock
  • Dot Mylar Balloons (each)

    Dot Mylar Balloons (each)

    MSRP: $4.99 Clearance Price: $1.99
    In Stock
  • Decorations Back To Top
  • Elmo Candle (each)

    Elmo Candle (each)

    Our Price: $4.99
    Out of Stock
  • Elmo Cake Pan (each)

    Elmo Cake Pan (each)

    Our Price: $16.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Street 1st Birthday Centerpiece (3 Centerpieces And Confetti)

    Sesame Street 1st Birthday Centerpiece (3 Centerpieces And Confetti)

    Our Price: $5.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Street 1st Birthday Bib (each)

    Sesame Street 1st Birthday Bib (each)

    Our Price: $3.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Street Elmo Cupcake and Treat Stand (Each)

    Sesame Street Elmo Cupcake and Treat Stand (Each)

    Our Price: $7.99
    Out of Stock
  • Sesame Street 1st Birthday Candle (set)

    Sesame Street 1st Birthday Candle (set)

    Our Price: $3.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Street 1st Birthday Hanging Decorations

    Sesame Street 1st Birthday Hanging Decorations

    Our Price: $4.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Street 1st Birthday Banner (set)

    Sesame Street 1st Birthday Banner (set)

    MSRP: $8.99 Our Price: $5.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Street 1st Birthday Highchair Kit (1 Set)

    Sesame Street 1st Birthday Highchair Kit (1 Set)

    Our Price: $5.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Street 1st Birthday Confetti

    Sesame Street 1st Birthday Confetti

    Our Price: $3.49
    In Stock
  • Solid Crepe Streamers (each)

    Solid Crepe Streamers (each)

    Our Price: $0.99
    In Stock
  • 1st Birthday Pink Tutu 37" High Chair Decoration (Each)

    1st Birthday Pink Tutu 37" High Chair Decoration (Each)

    Our Price: $9.99
    Out of Stock
  • Gold Star Confetti .5oz (Each)

    Gold Star Confetti .5oz (Each)

    MSRP: $3.74 Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
  • 1st Birthday Pink Glitter Photo Garland Decoration (Each)

    1st Birthday Pink Glitter Photo Garland Decoration (Each)

    Our Price: $7.99
    In Stock
  • 1st Birthday Blue 14" Glitter Centerpiece (Each)

    1st Birthday Blue 14" Glitter Centerpiece (Each)

    Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
  • Sticky Tack Value Pack

    Sticky Tack Value Pack

    Our Price: $3.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Number Pick Style Candles (Each)

    Number Pick Style Candles (Each)

    Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
  • Rainbow Paper Garland 12' Decoration (Each)

    Rainbow Paper Garland 12' Decoration (Each)

    Our Price: $3.99
    In Stock
  • Honeycomb 8" Ball Decoration (Each)

    Honeycomb 8" Ball Decoration (Each)

    Our Price: $1.49
    In Stock
  • 1st Birthday Blue Glitter Photo Garland Decoration (Each)

    1st Birthday Blue Glitter Photo Garland Decoration (Each)

    Our Price: $7.99
    In Stock
  • Pick Style Number Candles (each)

    Pick Style Number Candles (each)

    Our Price: $0.89
    In Stock
  • 1st Birthday Blue 37" High Chair Decoration (Each)

    1st Birthday Blue 37" High Chair Decoration (Each)

    Our Price: $9.99
    In Stock
  • 1st Birthday Blue Fluffy Hanging Decorations (3 Pack)

    1st Birthday Blue Fluffy Hanging Decorations (3 Pack)

    Our Price: $6.99
    Out of Stock
  • 1st Birthday Pink Fluffy Hanging Decorations (16 Pack)

    1st Birthday Pink Fluffy Hanging Decorations (16 Pack)

    Our Price: $6.99
    In Stock
  • Extra Large 5" Candles (Each)

    Extra Large 5" Candles (Each)

    Our Price: $2.99
    In Stock
  • 1st Birthday Pink 14" Glitter Centerpiece (Each)

    1st Birthday Pink 14" Glitter Centerpiece (Each)

    Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
  • Personalized Items Back To Top
  • Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Invitation (each)

    Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Invitation (each)

    Our Price: $0.99
    In Stock
  • Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Thank You Note (each)

    Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Thank You Note (each)

    Our Price: $0.99
    In Stock
  • Alphabet Personalized Coloring Book (each)

    Alphabet Personalized Coloring Book (each)

    Our Price: $2.99
    In Stock
    CHOKING HAZARD--Pin contains a functional sharp point. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Activity Mats (8-pack)

    Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Activity Mats (8-pack)

    Our Price: $6.99
    In Stock
  • Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Address Labels (sheet of 15)

    Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Address Labels (sheet of 15)

    Our Price: $2.99
    In Stock
  • Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Bag Tag (each)

    Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Bag Tag (each)

    Our Price: $2.99
    In Stock
  • Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Button (each)

    Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Button (each)

    Our Price: $1.79
    In Stock
    CHOKING HAZARD--Pin contains a functional sharp point. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Mini Button (each)

    Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Mini Button (each)

    Our Price: $0.99
    In Stock
    CHOKING HAZARD--Pin contains a functional sharp point. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Luggage Tag (each)

    Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Luggage Tag (each)

    Our Price: $2.99
    In Stock
  • Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Magnet (each)

    Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Magnet (each)

    Our Price: $1.79
    In Stock
  • Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Mini Magnet (each)

    Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Mini Magnet (each)

    Our Price: $0.99
    In Stock
  • Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Bookmark (each)

    Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Bookmark (each)

    Our Price: $2.99
    In Stock
  • Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Placemat (each)

    Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Placemat (each)

    Our Price: $7.99
    In Stock
  • Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Lollipops (pack of 12)

    Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Lollipops (pack of 12)

    Our Price: $13.99
    In Stock
  • Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Stickers (sheet of 12)

    Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Stickers (sheet of 12)

    Our Price: $3.99
    In Stock
  • Fuzzy Friends 1St Birthday Personalized Glass Apothecary Jars (10 Count)

    Fuzzy Friends 1St Birthday Personalized Glass Apothecary Jars (10 Count)

    Our Price: $19.99
    In Stock
  • Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Lip Balm (12 Pack)

    Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Lip Balm (12 Pack)

    Our Price: $9.99
    In Stock
  • Fuzzy Friends 1St Birthday Personalized Glass Milk Bottles (10 Count)

    Fuzzy Friends 1St Birthday Personalized Glass Milk Bottles (10 Count)

    Our Price: $19.99
    In Stock
  • Fuzzy Friends 1St Birthday Personalized Mini Paint Cans (12 Count)

    Fuzzy Friends 1St Birthday Personalized Mini Paint Cans (12 Count)

    Our Price: $17.99
    In Stock
  • Fuzzy Friends 1St Birthday Personalized Plain Glass Jars (10 Count)

    Fuzzy Friends 1St Birthday Personalized Plain Glass Jars (10 Count)

    Our Price: $19.99
    In Stock
  • Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Mini Stickers (Sheet of 20)

    Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Mini Stickers (Sheet of 20)

    Our Price: $2.99
    In Stock
  • Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Mini Zipper Pull (each)

    Fuzzy Friends 1st Birthday Personalized Mini Zipper Pull (each)

    Our Price: $0.99
    In Stock
    CHOKING HAZARD--Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Sesame Friends Personalized Glass Apothecary Jars (10 Count)

    Sesame Friends Personalized Glass Apothecary Jars (10 Count)

    Our Price: $19.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Friends Personalized Bottle Labels (Sheet of 4)

    Sesame Friends Personalized Bottle Labels (Sheet of 4)

    Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Friends Personalized 1" Carabiner (Each)

    Sesame Friends Personalized 1" Carabiner (Each)

    Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Friends Personalized Favor Mugs (Each)

    Sesame Friends Personalized Favor Mugs (Each)

    Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Friends Personalized 2.25" Key Chain (Each)

    Sesame Friends Personalized 2.25" Key Chain (Each)

    Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Friends Personalized 1" Mini Key Chain (Each)

    Sesame Friends Personalized 1" Mini Key Chain (Each)

    Our Price: $1.29
    In Stock
  • Sesame Friends Personalized Lip Balm (12 Pack)

    Sesame Friends Personalized Lip Balm (12 Pack)

    Our Price: $9.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Friends Personalized Glass Milk Bottles (10 Count)

    Sesame Friends Personalized Glass Milk Bottles (10 Count)

    Our Price: $19.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Friends Personalized Mini Paint Cans (12 Count)

    Sesame Friends Personalized Mini Paint Cans (12 Count)

    Our Price: $17.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Friends Personalized Plain Glass Jars (10 Count)

    Sesame Friends Personalized Plain Glass Jars (10 Count)

    Our Price: $19.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Friends Personalized Mini Stickers (Sheet of 20)

    Sesame Friends Personalized Mini Stickers (Sheet of 20)

    Our Price: $2.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Personalized 2" Lollipops (20 Pack)

    Sesame Personalized 2" Lollipops (20 Pack)

    Our Price: $9.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Friends Personalized Bubbles (18 Pack)

    Sesame Friends Personalized Bubbles (18 Pack)

    Our Price: $9.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Friends Personalized Favor Bag (Set Of 12)

    Sesame Friends Personalized Favor Bag (Set Of 12)

    Our Price: $5.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Friends Personalized Candy Bar Wrapper (Each)

    Sesame Friends Personalized Candy Bar Wrapper (Each)

    Our Price: $0.79
    In Stock
  • Sesame Personalized Paint Can Favor Container (6 Pack)

    Sesame Personalized Paint Can Favor Container (6 Pack)

    Our Price: $15.99
    In Stock
  • More Fun Stuff! Back To Top
  • Sesame Street 1st Birthday Party Blowers (8-pack)

    Sesame Street 1st Birthday Party Blowers (8-pack)

    Our Price: $3.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Street 1st Birthday Party Hats (8-pack)

    Sesame Street 1st Birthday Party Hats (8-pack)

    Our Price: $3.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Street 1st Birthday Elmo Hat (each)

    Sesame Street 1st Birthday Elmo Hat (each)

    Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Street Elmo Cupcake and Treat Stand (Each)

    Sesame Street Elmo Cupcake and Treat Stand (Each)

    Our Price: $7.99
    Out of Stock
  • Solid Party Hats (8-pack)

    Solid Party Hats (8-pack)

    Our Price: $0.99
    In Stock
  • Autograph Photo White Matte (Each)

    Autograph Photo White Matte (Each)

    Our Price: $4.99
    In Stock
  • Sticky Tack Value Pack

    Sticky Tack Value Pack

    Our Price: $3.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • 1St Birthday Crown Felt Headband (Each)

    1St Birthday Crown Felt Headband (Each)

    Our Price: $5.99
    In Stock
  • Craft Glue Dots (30-sheets)

    Craft Glue Dots (30-sheets)

    MSRP: $17.59 Clearance Price: $5.99
    In Stock
    CHOKING HAZARD--Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Elmo Pull-String Pinata

    Elmo Pull-String Pinata

    Our Price: $22.99
    In Stock
  • Elmo Pull-String Pinata

    Elmo Pull-String Pinata

    Our Price: $15.99
    In Stock
  • Handprint Kit (makes 1)

    Handprint Kit (makes 1)

    Our Price: $7.99
    In Stock
    CHOKING HAZARD--Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Extra Large 5" Candles (Each)

    Extra Large 5" Candles (Each)

    Our Price: $2.99
    In Stock
  • 1St Birthday Boy Autograph Frame (Each)

    1St Birthday Boy Autograph Frame (Each)

    Our Price: $4.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Cupcake Baking Cups (50 Pack)

    Sesame Cupcake Baking Cups (50 Pack)

    Our Price: $2.99
    Out of Stock
  • Elmo Bean Bag

    Elmo Bean Bag

    Our Price: $8.99
    Out of Stock
  • Sesame Street Party  2" Edible Cupcake Topper (12 Images)

    Sesame Street Party 2" Edible Cupcake Topper (12 Images)

    Our Price: $9.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Street Party  Quarter Sheet Edible Cake Topper (Each)

    Sesame Street Party Quarter Sheet Edible Cake Topper (Each)

    Our Price: $9.99
    In Stock
  • Sesame Street Party  7.5" Round Edible Cake Topper (Each)

    Sesame Street Party 7.5" Round Edible Cake Topper (Each)

    Our Price: $9.99
    In Stock
  • COOKIE MONSTER HAND PUPPET

    COOKIE MONSTER HAND PUPPET

    Our Price: $17.99
    In Stock
  • PLUSH ELMO

    PLUSH ELMO

    Our Price: $17.99
    In Stock
  • PLUSH COOKIE

    PLUSH COOKIE

    Our Price: $17.99
    In Stock
  • Cookie Beanbag

    Cookie Beanbag

    Our Price: $8.99
    Out of Stock
  • PLUSH BERT

    PLUSH BERT

    Our Price: $17.99
    In Stock
  • PLUSH OSCAR

    PLUSH OSCAR

    Our Price: $17.99
    In Stock
  • TAKE ALONG BUDDY ELMO

    TAKE ALONG BUDDY ELMO

    Our Price: $16.99
    In Stock
  • ROSITA

    ROSITA

    Our Price: $17.99
    In Stock
  • PLUSH BIG BIRD

    PLUSH BIG BIRD

    Our Price: $17.99
    Out of Stock
  • PLUSH GROVER

    PLUSH GROVER

    Our Price: $17.99
    Out of Stock
  • Grover Beanbag

    Grover Beanbag

    Our Price: $8.99
    In Stock
  • 20" ELMO

    20" ELMO

    Our Price: $34.99
    In Stock
  • Cookie Finger Puppet

    Cookie Finger Puppet

    Our Price: $7.99
    In Stock
  • BERT HAND PUPPET

    BERT HAND PUPPET

    Our Price: $17.99
    In Stock
  • Big Bird Beanbag

    Big Bird Beanbag

    Our Price: $8.99
    Out of Stock
  • SLEEPYTIME ELMO

    SLEEPYTIME ELMO

    Our Price: $24.99
    Out of Stock
  • ZOE FB PUPPET

    ZOE FB PUPPET

    Our Price: $24.99
    In Stock
  • ZOE HAND PUPPET

    ZOE HAND PUPPET

    Our Price: $17.99
    In Stock
  • PLUSH SNUFFLEUPAGUS

    PLUSH SNUFFLEUPAGUS

    Our Price: $17.99
    Out of Stock
  • GIANT COOKIE MONSTER

    GIANT COOKIE MONSTER

    Our Price: $149.99
    In Stock
  • ROSITA BEANBAG

    ROSITA BEANBAG

    Our Price: $8.99
    In Stock
  • TAKE ALONG BUDDY BIG BIRD

    TAKE ALONG BUDDY BIG BIRD

    Our Price: $14.99
    Out of Stock
  • ABBY FB PUPPET

    ABBY FB PUPPET

    Our Price: $24.99
    Out of Stock
  • COOKIE FB PUPPET

    COOKIE FB PUPPET

    Our Price: $24.99
    In Stock
  • Character Plush Zoe

    Character Plush Zoe

    Our Price: $27.99
    In Stock
  • ERNIE HAND PUPPET

    ERNIE HAND PUPPET

    Our Price: $17.99
    In Stock
  • 41" ELMO

    41" ELMO

    Our Price: $149.99
    In Stock
  • BEST FRIENDS ELMO

    BEST FRIENDS ELMO

    Our Price: $29.99
    Out of Stock
  • TAKE ALONG BUDDY ABBY

    TAKE ALONG BUDDY ABBY

    Our Price: $19.99
    Out of Stock
  • Bucket And Shovel (each)

    Bucket And Shovel (each)

    Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
    CHOKING HAZARD--Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • 1St Birthday 14.5" Sash (Each)

    1St Birthday 14.5" Sash (Each)

    Our Price: $4.99
    Out of Stock
  • Elmo Jumbo Pinata

    Elmo Jumbo Pinata

    Our Price: $49.99
    In Stock
  • ELMO FULL BODY PUPPET

    ELMO FULL BODY PUPPET

    Our Price: $24.99
    Out of Stock
  • PLUSH ERNIE

    PLUSH ERNIE

    Our Price: $17.99
    Out of Stock
  • However, if you would like to create your own unique celebration area, you can purchase all of our party supplies and items separately. We have a wide selection of items that will make turning your home into a celebration station as easy as 1-2-3. These include cups, napkins, plates, cutlery, confetti, balloons, streamers and more.

    For some added fun at the gathering, we have a selection of different pinatas and games that will keep kids entertained and having a great time all throughout the party.

    Be sure to finish off your event by sending your guests home with the perfect Sesame Street first birthday party favor kit. You can create your own by selecting different items or you can use one of our pre-made kits.

    Either way, this 1st birthday party will have all your guests wanting to return to Sesame Street!