Pony Party

Prepare the saddles because your daughter and her friends are in for a birthday party that's bound to be a ton of fun. The Pony Party theme features beautiful and strong horses roaming lush fields. The girls will certainly be in awe over how nice all the decorations will look. Preparing the table for your daughter's birthday will be simple task because ordering supplies for this theme is a snap. We have matching theme cups, napkins, plates, and other essential items available in packs, so simply order however many you need and you're good to go.

Pony Party party supplies


Tableware Back To Top
Create your own themed party or add to your party
  • Pony Party Cake Plates (8-pack)

    Pony Party Cake Plates (8-pack)

    MSRP: $3.99 Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Pony Party Beverage Napkins (16-pack)

    Pony Party Beverage Napkins (16-pack)

    MSRP: $3.99 Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Pony Party Dinner Plates (8-pack)

    Pony Party Dinner Plates (8-pack)

    MSRP: $4.99 Our Price: $2.49
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Pony Party Napkins (16-pack)

    Pony Party Napkins (16-pack)

    MSRP: $4.99 Our Price: $2.49
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Pony Party Cups (8-pack)

    Pony Party Cups (8-pack)

    MSRP: $4.39 Our Price: $2.19
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Pony Party Table Cover (each)

    Pony Party Table Cover (each)

    MSRP: $5.39 Our Price: $4.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Blue Tableware

    Blue Tableware

  • Lime Tableware

    Lime Tableware

  • Lemon Yellow Tableware

    Lemon Yellow Tableware

  • All-In-One Party Kits Back To Top
  • Pony Party Decoration Kit

    Pony Party Decoration Kit

    Our Price: $21.49
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Pony Party Balloon Kit

    Pony Party Balloon Kit

    Our Price: $22.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Pony Birthday Party Standard Tableware Kit Serves 8

    Pony Birthday Party Standard Tableware Kit Serves 8

    Our Price: $7.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Horse Pinata Kit

    Horse Pinata Kit

    Our Price: $31.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Pony Birthday Party Deluxe Tableware Kit Serves 8

    Pony Birthday Party Deluxe Tableware Kit Serves 8

    Our Price: $14.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Pony Birthday Party Ultimate Tableware Birthday Kit Serves 8

    Pony Birthday Party Ultimate Tableware Birthday Kit Serves 8

    Our Price: $29.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Pony Party Favor Kit (for 1 Guest)

    Pony Party Favor Kit (for 1 Guest)

    Our Price: $4.79
    Out of Stock
    Qty:
    CHOKING HAZARD--Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Pony Party Deluxe Favor Kit (for 1 Guest)

    Pony Party Deluxe Favor Kit (for 1 Guest)

    Our Price: $6.59
    Out of Stock
    Qty:
    CHOKING HAZARD--Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Birthday Pony Pull String Pinata Kit

    Birthday Pony Pull String Pinata Kit

    Our Price: $29.99
    Out of Stock
    Qty:
  • Party Favors & Candy Back To Top
  • Pony Party Personalized Lollipops (pack of 12)

    Pony Party Personalized Lollipops (pack of 12)

    Our Price: $13.99
    In Stock
  • Blue Candy

    Blue Candy

  • Green Candy

    Green Candy

  • Green Candy Buffet Decorating Kit (Each)

    Green Candy Buffet Decorating Kit (Each)

    Our Price: $64.99
    Out of Stock
    Qty:
  • Pony Party Favor Kit (for 1 Guest)

    Pony Party Favor Kit (for 1 Guest)

    Our Price: $4.79
    Out of Stock
    Qty:
    CHOKING HAZARD--Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Pony Party Deluxe Favor Kit (for 1 Guest)

    Pony Party Deluxe Favor Kit (for 1 Guest)

    Our Price: $6.59
    Out of Stock
    Qty:
    CHOKING HAZARD--Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Pony Party Stickers (4-pack)

    Pony Party Stickers (4-pack)

    MSRP: $1.94 Our Price: $1.49
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Horse Figure (each)

    Horse Figure (each)

    Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Large Swirl Lollipops (12 Ct )

    Large Swirl Lollipops (12 Ct )

    Our Price: $9.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Mini Watercolor Paint Set (6-pack)

    Mini Watercolor Paint Set (6-pack)

    Our Price: $4.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Rainbow Scratch Art Boards Set (Each)

    Rainbow Scratch Art Boards Set (Each)

    Our Price: $1.49
    Out of Stock
    Qty:
  • Candy Necklace (24 Count)

    Candy Necklace (24 Count)

    Our Price: $8.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Swirl Lollipop (12-pack)

    Swirl Lollipop (12-pack)

    Our Price: $6.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Mini Uno Game (4-pack)

    Mini Uno Game (4-pack)

    Our Price: $4.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Yellow Treat Favor Boxes (6 Pack)

    Yellow Treat Favor Boxes (6 Pack)

    Our Price: $2.49
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Wacky Whirler (each)

    Wacky Whirler (each)

    Our Price: $0.79
    In Stock
    Qty:
    CHOKING HAZARD--Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Bright Canvas Pencil Case (12 Pack)

    Bright Canvas Pencil Case (12 Pack)

    Our Price: $12.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Blue Treat Favor Boxes (6 Pack)

    Blue Treat Favor Boxes (6 Pack)

    Our Price: $2.49
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Solid Colored Notepads (12-pack)

    Solid Colored Notepads (12-pack)

    Our Price: $2.29
    Out of Stock
    Qty:
  • Solid Drawstring Backpacks (each)

    Solid Drawstring Backpacks (each)

    Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Loom Rubber Bands (300 Pieces)

    Loom Rubber Bands (300 Pieces)

    MSRP: $2.49 Clearance Price: $0.69

  • Green Treat Favor Boxes (6 Pack)

    Green Treat Favor Boxes (6 Pack)

    Our Price: $2.49
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Pink Star Bubble Necklace (4-pack)

    Pink Star Bubble Necklace (4-pack)

    Our Price: $2.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
    CHOKING HAZARD--Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Ring Pop (15 Count)

    Ring Pop (15 Count)

    Our Price: $9.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Pixy Stix (144 Count)

    Pixy Stix (144 Count)

    Our Price: $9.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Denim Drawstring Backpack (12 Pack)

    Denim Drawstring Backpack (12 Pack)

    Our Price: $24.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Mini Game Bubbles (each)

    Mini Game Bubbles (each)

    Our Price: $1.19
    In Stock
    Qty:
    CHOKING HAZARD--Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Mini Bubble Tubes (8-pack)

    Mini Bubble Tubes (8-pack)

    Our Price: $2.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
    CHOKING HAZARD--Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Galaxy Hi-bounce Ball (50 Count)

    Galaxy Hi-bounce Ball (50 Count)

    Our Price: $19.99
    Out of Stock
    Qty:
  • Bandana Print Favor Tote Bag (12 pack)

    Bandana Print Favor Tote Bag (12 pack)

    Our Price: $8.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Elastic Bands Lolliband Favor (Each)

    Elastic Bands Lolliband Favor (Each)

    Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Pony Party Personalized Lip Balm (12 Pack)

    Pony Party Personalized Lip Balm (12 Pack)

    Our Price: $9.99
    In Stock
  • Pony Personalized Favor Bag (Set Of 12)

    Pony Personalized Favor Bag (Set Of 12)

    Our Price: $5.99
    In Stock
  • Flower Straw (2-pack)

    Flower Straw (2-pack)

    Our Price: $1.99
    Out of Stock
    Qty:
  • Balloons Back To Top
  • Pony Party Balloon Kit

    Pony Party Balloon Kit

    Our Price: $22.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Pony 18" Balloon (Each)

    Pony 18" Balloon (Each)

    MSRP: $2.99 Our Price: $2.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Horse Balloon (each)

    Horse Balloon (each)

    Our Price: $6.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Solid Curling Ribbon (each)

    Solid Curling Ribbon (each)

    Our Price: $0.69

  • Solid Latex Balloons (10-pack)

    Solid Latex Balloons (10-pack)

    Our Price: $1.29

    CHOKING HAZARD--Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Balloon Drop Bag 80" (Each)

    Balloon Drop Bag 80" (Each)

    Our Price: $3.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Latex 12" Dots Balloons (6 Pack)

    Latex 12" Dots Balloons (6 Pack)

    Our Price: $1.99

  • 50ft Balloon Decorating Strip (Each)

    50ft Balloon Decorating Strip (Each)

    Our Price: $7.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Mylar Number Balloons (each)

    Mylar Number Balloons (each)

    Our Price: $7.99

  • Balloon Pump (each)

    Balloon Pump (each)

    Our Price: $4.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • 25ft Balloon Decorating Strip (Each)

    25ft Balloon Decorating Strip (Each)

    Our Price: $3.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Ultra Hi-Float Balloon Treatment Kit 16oz (Each)

    Ultra Hi-Float Balloon Treatment Kit 16oz (Each)

    Our Price: $11.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Premium Assorted Latex 36" Balloons (6 Pack)

    Premium Assorted Latex 36" Balloons (6 Pack)

    Our Price: $14.99
    Out of Stock
    Qty:
  • Disposable Helium Tank 14.9 Cubic Ft.

    Disposable Helium Tank 14.9 Cubic Ft.

    Our Price: $59.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Dot Mylar Balloons (each)

    Dot Mylar Balloons (each)

    MSRP: $4.99 Clearance Price: $1.99

  • Decorations Back To Top
  • Horse Pinata (each)

    Horse Pinata (each)

    Our Price: $14.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Pony Party Centerpiece (each)

    Pony Party Centerpiece (each)

    Our Price: $5.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Pony Party Banner (each)

    Pony Party Banner (each)

    MSRP: $4.49 Our Price: $4.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Pony Cake Pan (each)

    Pony Cake Pan (each)

    Our Price: $16.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Pony Party Dangling Cutout (3-pack)

    Pony Party Dangling Cutout (3-pack)

    MSRP: $4.19 Our Price: $4.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Birthday Candles (12-pack)

    Birthday Candles (12-pack)

    Our Price: $1.19
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Solid Crepe Streamers (each)

    Solid Crepe Streamers (each)

    Our Price: $0.99

  • Gold Star Confetti .5oz (Each)

    Gold Star Confetti .5oz (Each)

    MSRP: $3.74 Our Price: $1.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Number Pick Style Candles (Each)

    Number Pick Style Candles (Each)

    Our Price: $1.99

  • Multicolored Honeycomb Tissue Ball (each)

    Multicolored Honeycomb Tissue Ball (each)

    Our Price: $2.99
    Out of Stock
    Qty:
  • Paper Party Lanterns (each)

    Paper Party Lanterns (each)

    MSRP: $4.99 Clearance Price: $2.19

  • Pick Style Number Candles (each)

    Pick Style Number Candles (each)

    Our Price: $0.89

  • Happy Birthday Candles - Primary (each)

    Happy Birthday Candles - Primary (each)

    Our Price: $3.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Personalized Items Back To Top
  • Pony Party Personalized Invitation (each)

    Pony Party Personalized Invitation (each)

    Our Price: $0.99
    In Stock
  • Pony Party Personalized Thank You Note (each)

    Pony Party Personalized Thank You Note (each)

    Our Price: $0.99
    In Stock
  • Pony Party Personalized Bag Tag (each)

    Pony Party Personalized Bag Tag (each)

    Our Price: $2.99
    In Stock
  • Pony Party Personalized Stickers (sheet of 12)

    Pony Party Personalized Stickers (sheet of 12)

    Our Price: $3.99
    In Stock
  • Pony Party Personalized Glass Apothecary Jars (10 Count)

    Pony Party Personalized Glass Apothecary Jars (10 Count)

    Our Price: $19.99
    In Stock
  • Pony Party Personalized Lip Balm (12 Pack)

    Pony Party Personalized Lip Balm (12 Pack)

    Our Price: $9.99
    In Stock
  • Pony Party Personalized Glass Milk Bottles (10 Count)

    Pony Party Personalized Glass Milk Bottles (10 Count)

    Our Price: $19.99
    Sorry, this item is unavailable.
  • Pony Party Personalized Mini Paint Cans (12 Count)

    Pony Party Personalized Mini Paint Cans (12 Count)

    Our Price: $17.99
    In Stock
  • Pony Party Personalized Plain Glass Jars (10 Count)

    Pony Party Personalized Plain Glass Jars (10 Count)

    Our Price: $19.99
    In Stock
  • Pony Party Personalized Magnet (each)

    Pony Party Personalized Magnet (each)

    Our Price: $1.79
    In Stock
  • Pony Party Personalized Button (each)

    Pony Party Personalized Button (each)

    Our Price: $1.79
    In Stock
    CHOKING HAZARD--Pin contains a functional sharp point. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Pony Party Personalized Mini Zipper Pull (each)

    Pony Party Personalized Mini Zipper Pull (each)

    Our Price: $1.29
    In Stock
    CHOKING HAZARD--Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Pony Party Personalized Placemat (each)

    Pony Party Personalized Placemat (each)

    Our Price: $7.99
    In Stock
  • Pony Party Personalized Bookmark (each)

    Pony Party Personalized Bookmark (each)

    Our Price: $2.99
    In Stock
  • Pony Party Personalized Mini Magnet (each)

    Pony Party Personalized Mini Magnet (each)

    Our Price: $0.99
    In Stock
  • Pony Party Personalized Mini Button (each)

    Pony Party Personalized Mini Button (each)

    Our Price: $0.99
    In Stock
    CHOKING HAZARD--Pin contains a functional sharp point. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Pony Party Personalized Lollipops (pack of 12)

    Pony Party Personalized Lollipops (pack of 12)

    Our Price: $13.99
    In Stock
  • Pony Party Personalized Luggage Tag (each)

    Pony Party Personalized Luggage Tag (each)

    Our Price: $2.99
    In Stock
  • Pony Party Personalized Address Labels (Sheet of 15)

    Pony Party Personalized Address Labels (Sheet of 15)

    Our Price: $2.99
    In Stock
  • Pony Party Personalized Activity Mats (8-Pack)

    Pony Party Personalized Activity Mats (8-Pack)

    Our Price: $6.99
    In Stock
  • Pony Personalized Favor Bag (Set Of 12)

    Pony Personalized Favor Bag (Set Of 12)

    Our Price: $5.99
    In Stock
  • Pony Party Personalized Rectangular Stickers (Sheet of 15)

    Pony Party Personalized Rectangular Stickers (Sheet of 15)

    Our Price: $2.99
    In Stock
  • Invitations & Thank You's Back To Top
  • Pony Party Personalized Invitation (each)

    Pony Party Personalized Invitation (each)

    Our Price: $0.99
    In Stock
  • Pony Party Personalized Thank You Note (each)

    Pony Party Personalized Thank You Note (each)

    Our Price: $0.99
    In Stock
  • Pony Party Invitations (8-pack)

    Pony Party Invitations (8-pack)

    MSRP: $3.74 Our Price: $3.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • More Fun Stuff! Back To Top
  • Pin The Tail On The Donkey Game (for 24 Players)

    Pin The Tail On The Donkey Game (for 24 Players)

    Our Price: $3.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Pony Party Hats (8-pack)

    Pony Party Hats (8-pack)

    MSRP: $3.44 Our Price: $3.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Pony Party Blowers (8-pack)

    Pony Party Blowers (8-pack)

    MSRP: $3.44 Our Price: $3.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Solid Party Hats (8-pack)

    Solid Party Hats (8-pack)

    Our Price: $0.99

  • Assorted Bright Color Party Hats (8-pack)

    Assorted Bright Color Party Hats (8-pack)

    Our Price: $3.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Mini Uno Game (4-pack)

    Mini Uno Game (4-pack)

    Our Price: $4.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Child Cowboy Hat (Each)

    Child Cowboy Hat (Each)

    MSRP: $5.99 Our Price: $3.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Autograph Photo White Matte (Each)

    Autograph Photo White Matte (Each)

    Our Price: $4.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Pink Cowgirl Hat (each)

    Pink Cowgirl Hat (each)

    MSRP: $5.99 Our Price: $3.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Blue Cowboy Hat (each)

    Blue Cowboy Hat (each)

    MSRP: $5.99 Our Price: $3.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
  • Craft Glue Dots (30-sheets)

    Craft Glue Dots (30-sheets)

    MSRP: $17.59 Clearance Price: $5.99
    In Stock
    Qty:
    CHOKING HAZARD--Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
  • Candy Jewelry Kit (each)

    Candy Jewelry Kit (each)

    Our Price: $1.99
    Out of Stock
    Qty:
  • Birthday Pony Pull String Pinata

    Birthday Pony Pull String Pinata

    Our Price: $15.99
    Out of Stock
    Qty:
  • And for an added convenience, we even have all these items and additional decorative goodies available in three different kits, all of which serve eight. If you were to order the Pony Party Ultimate Birthday Kit, you would also receive party hats and blowers, streamers, and much more.

    Your daughter will be ecstatic over the entire celebration, especially if you choose to add personalized items to the birthday setting. By simply entering her name or a special message into the designated box of your desired personalized item, you can have it delivered exactly as specified. Her name could be featured on a beautiful birthday banner with two horses standing stoically in a green field under a large blue sky.

    Whether it's decorations, favors, or any other items, all will be equally easy and simple to order. You will create a lovely Pony Party for your daughter and not have to fret over any details.